Play the Reindeer Poop Game for Hilarious Gross Christmas Fun
Look, I never thought I’d be writing an article about fake reindeer droppings, but here we are. And I’m not even sorry, lol
Let me introduce you to the Reindeer Poop Game – the holiday party activity that turns your guests into chocolate-sniffing detectives.
Annnnnnd it also proves that sometimes the best Christmas entertainment is a little bit gross. You’re definitely gonna want to play this one. Shall we?
What in the Holiday Spirit is the Reindeer Poop Game?
Let’s just say that you’re at a Christmas party, and someone hands you a plate with what appears to be… well, let’s just say it looks questionable.
Plot twist – it’s actually melted chocolate, and you’re supposed to figure out which candy bar it used to be. Honestly, I can’t decide if this is brilliant or bonkers, but it works every single time.
The concept is pretty simple: 5-10 different chocolate bars get transformed into unidentifiable blobs, and players compete to guess their original identities.
Think of it as CSI: Christmas Special Edition, minus the fancy lab equipment.
Don’t Let Christmas Be a Snooze Fest!
Become the hero of Christmas gatherings with this fun, FREE Christmas Movie Bingo pack. Hunt for classics like “The Grinch,” “Miracle on 34th Street,” and “Frosty” with 25 unique cards perfect for 2 players or 20. Create memories, no matter your crowd size.
Getting Your Supplies Together (Without Looking Suspicious)
Here’s what you’ll need to pull off this questionably classy game:
- Popular chocolate bars (5-10 varieties that people can actually recognize)
- Parchment paper (trust me, you’ll thank me later)
- Numbered paper plates
- Black marker
- Pens and paper for your brave participants
- Reindeer-themed prizes (because nothing says “congratulations on identifying poop” like a plush Rudolf)
Chocolate Bar Suggestions for the Game
- Snickers
- Milky Way
- Twix
- Kit Kat
- Reese’s Fast Break
- Butterfinger
- 3 Musketeers
- Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bar
- Almond Joy
- Mounds
- PayDay
- Crunch
Can’t get enough of these festive shenanigans? dramatic pause I’ve got a whole sleigh-full of holiday party games that’ll make your grandma clutch her pearls – in the best way possible! From the wild and wacky Saran Wrap Ball Game to the neighborhood-touring Christmas Lights Scavenger Hunt, and the jolly twist on a classic with the Christmas Guess Who Game. Your holiday party game arsenal just got a serious upgrade!
The Setup: Transforming Perfectly Good Chocolate Into “Evidence”
Let me share my hard-earned wisdom about melting chocolate bars:
| Do This | Don’t Do This |
|---|---|
| Use low heat | Nuke it on high (unless you enjoy cleaning exploded chocolate) |
| Check frequently | Walk away to watch TikTok |
| Space bars apart | Create one mega-blob |
| Track varieties | Forget what’s what |
| Cool before plating | Serve molten chaos |
Find a private spot to melt your chocolate. Nothing ruins the surprise quite like your guests watching you deliberately destroy perfectly good candy bars.
Reindeer Poop Christmas Game Rules: Because We Need Some Structure in This Chaos
even when we’re playing with fake reindeer droppings, we need some ground rules. Here’s how to keep your chocolate chaos organized:
- Number each “specimen” clearly
- Use bold numbers on plates
- Keep a master list (because mixing up your Mars bars and Snickers would be tragic)
- Pro tip: Write numbers on plate bottoms too – chocolate can get messy
- Give players paper to write their guesses
- Provide sheets and pens
- Have everyone number the papers based on how many “reindeer poop” paper plates you have.
- You can give people a word bank of possible candy bars (unless you’re feeling evil)
- Allow sniffing and tasting (if they’re brave enough)
- Provide toothpicks for the squeamish
- Keep water nearby for palate cleansing
- Personal note: You haven’t lived until you’ve watched your prim aunt turn into a chocolate sommelier
- Set a time limit (5-10 minutes works well)
- 5 minutes for casual players
- 10 minutes if you’ve got serious candy enthusiasts
- Use a timer – nothing motivates like the fear of time running out
- Compare guesses to the actual answers
- Create suspense by revealing one at a time
- Start with the easy ones (everyone needs a win)
- Save the tricky ones for last
- Award points for correct guesses
- 1 point per correct guess
- Consider bonus points for accurate descriptions
- Optional: Extra points for identifying special ingredients
- Crown your champion chocolate detective
- Make it theatrical – this is their moment
- Award a ridiculous trophy
- Take photos for future blackmail material
From reindeer droppings to Santa’s jolly face – keep the Christmas chaos rolling! Check out this fantastic printable Santa craft from my friend at The Craft at Home Family. Because sometimes you need a break from poop jokes (but just sometimes).
Age-Appropriate Modifications (Because Not Everyone Appreciates Poop Jokes Equally)
For the Little Ones (Under 8)
Keep it simple – let them match wrapped candy bars to their melted versions. They’ll feel like tiny detectives without getting too confused.
For Teens & Adults
Throw in some challenges:
- Add a timer
- Include rare candy varieties
- Make them taste-test blindfolded (evil laugh)
Prize Ideas That Won’t End Up in the Trash
Because nothing says “you’re a winner” quite like:
- Gift cards disguised in reindeer-themed holders
- Chocolate-filled “Bags of Reindeer Poo” (meta, right?)
- Holiday ornaments (preferably reindeer-themed)
- Plush reindeer (for the softies in the crowd)
Keep some wet wipes handy. Someone is going to touch the Nothing kills the holiday spirit quite like chocolate-stained formal wear.
Why This Game Actually Works (Despite Being Absolutely Ridiculous)
Let’s be real – this game shouldn’t work. It’s basically asking people to analyze fake poop at a holiday party.
But here’s the thing: it breaks the ice faster than your aunt’s awkward holiday stories, gets everyone laughing, and creates those “remember when” moments that family gatherings are made of.
Final Thoughts
Is the Reindeer Poop Game sophisticated? Absolutely not.
Will it make your holiday party memorable? You bet your chocolate-covered fingers it will.
Just remember: what happens at the reindeer poop game stays at the reindeer poop game – unless, of course, someone posts it on social media, in which case you’re on your own.